If you ask anyone to describe themselves, they’ll usually use a mix of personality traits, emotional states, and value judgments, such as “I am anxious, I am successful, I am shy, I am not good enough”. And, typically, people assume these opinions must somehow reflect objective reality – fixed, internal facts about who they are. They believe their low self-esteem, for example, is a personal failing, a character flaw they must somehow fix through sheer willpower.
What people rarely notice is where those words came from. Long before an individual forms an opinion of themself, other people have already been forming it for them – and they have absorbed the views of those other people so completely that the views start to feel like their own. An individual’s sense of self is not an internal biography, rather it is a social construct.
An individual’s sense of self develops through thousands of interactions with other people. From the day they were born, their brains were collecting information about who they are by observing how others respond to them. Parents, siblings, teachers, friends, colleagues, partners, and even strangers all contribute to the story they tell themself.
If an individual was raised on a desert island, alone, they would have no concept of ‘confidence’ or ‘inadequacy’. They would simply exist. They would not judge their appearance, their status, or their worth because self-esteem is an interpersonal transaction, not an internal possession.
For solution-focused hypnotherapists working therapeutically with clients – particularly around anxiety, low self-worth, perfectionism, or rejection sensitivity – understanding how the self gets built from the outside in changes how therapists understand both the problem and the solution. If many of a client’s limiting beliefs didn’t originate with them, but were learned, then we can help them to learn new positive beliefs about themselves.
The need for connection
Human beings are among the most social creatures on Earth. For thousands of years, survival for individuals depended on belonging to a group. A person who was rejected by their tribe faced a far greater risk of injury, starvation, or death. Human brains therefore evolved to pay enormous attention to social relationships. Being accepted, valued, and included is not simply pleasant – it is deeply connected to a person’s sense of safety.
This helps explain why criticism can hurt, why rejection feels like physical pain, why loneliness affects our physical health, and why a single encouraging comment can change someone’s entire day. The brain treats social information as information about survival.
Modern neuroscience supports the idea that human beings are biologically designed to regulate emotion together rather than alone. Social baseline theory (SBT), developed by James Coan and colleagues, proposes that the brain assumes supportive relationships are available when estimating the demands of the environment. In effect, the nervous system treats trusted companions as part of its normal operating conditions.
Research has shown that simply holding the hand of a trusted partner can reduce activity in brain regions associated with threat and emotional distress. The presence of supportive others quite literally changes how much danger the brain perceives and how many resources it believes it must expend to cope.
This helps explain why clients often feel calmer simply by talking to someone who listens without judgement. Safety is not created solely by changing thoughts; it also emerges through experiencing reliable, supportive relationships that allow the nervous system to relax.
Stephen Porges’ Polyvagal Theory introduced the concept of neuroception – the brain’s unconscious process of constantly scanning the environment for cues of safety, danger, or life threat. Unlike conscious perception, neuroception operates automatically and influences physiological state before we have time to think about what is happening.
Facial expressions, tone of voice, posture, eye contact, and body language all provide information that helps the nervous system decide whether another person feels safe. When neuroception detects safety, the social engagement system becomes active, making curiosity, learning, problem-solving, and emotional regulation easier. When danger is detected, defensive responses such as anxiety, withdrawal, hypervigilance, or anger become more likely.
For therapists, this highlights the importance of much more than the words spoken during a session. A calm voice, genuine warmth, attentive listening, and consistent emotional presence all help signal safety to the client’s nervous system, creating conditions in which psychological change becomes more likely.
Mirror image
Charles Horton Cooley (1864-1929) came up with the idea that people don’t develop a sense of self by looking inwards, but by imagining how we appear to others. He called it the “looking-glass self”, and introduced the idea in his 1902 book Human Nature and the Social Order. The process runs in three continuous stages – an individual imagines how they appear to the people around them, they imagine how others judge that appearance, and they develop a feeling (pride, shame, confidence, doubt, etc) based on those imagined judgments.
The crucial detail is that none of this requires the other person’s judgment to be accurate. It only requires that an individual believes it, and that belief becomes the raw material for that individual’s self-concept.
In his 1909 book Social Organization, Cooley introduced the distinction between different types of social structures. Primary groups are small, face-to-face, long-lasting groups that shape a person’s core values, such as families and close friend circles. Secondary groups are larger, impersonal, and goal-oriented groups where relationships are temporary, such as workplaces, classrooms, or political organizations.
Around the same time, George Herbert Mead extended the idea, arguing that identity itself is built through social interaction and language. An individual doesn’t arrive with a fixed self, waiting to be discovered – the self emerges through countless exchanges with others, and is refined over a lifetime.
Mead argued that the human self is a social process consisting of two distinct, interacting parts. The ‘I’ is the spontaneous, creative, impulsive, and unpredictable part of the self. It represents active personal identity and responds directly to social situations without filtering. The ‘Me’ is the socialized self that internalizes the attitudes, expectations, and rules of society. It acts as an internal social monitor, evaluating behaviour according to the expectations of others.
Unlike animals, humans learn to develop a self by learning to ‘take the role of the other’. Mead outlined three essential developmental stages in childhood:
The preparatory stage (imitation) – toddlers imitate gestures and words of those around them without understanding their deeper symbolic meaning.
The play stage – young children pretend to take on the specific roles of significant individuals, such as acting as a mother, teacher, or doctor.
The game stage – older children learn to manage multiple roles simultaneously and understand the structured rules of an entire activity, like playing a football match.
The final crown of social development in Mead’s framework is the creation of the ‘generalized other’. This concept represents the collective values, attitudes, and expectations of an entire society or community. Once a person internalizes the generalized other, they no longer need individual people to guide their behaviour. They can judge their own conduct against abstract societal norms.
Leon Festinger’s social comparison theory suggests that when we’re uncertain about our own abilities or worth, we look sideways rather than inward – measuring ourselves against others to work out where we stand. In the absence of an objective yardstick, other people become the yardstick.
In his social comparison theory in 1954, he thought that individuals have an innate drive to evaluate their own opinions, abilities, and achievements accurately. When objective, physical standards are unavailable, people judge themselves by comparing their traits and skills to others. Festinger and subsequent researchers identified two main ways people compare themselves to others. Upward comparison is where an individual compares themself to someone perceived as superior or better off. This can motivate self-improvement, but it frequently lowers self-esteem and triggers feelings of inadequacy. Downward comparison is where an individual compares themself to someone perceived as worse off or less skilled. This serves as a defensive mechanism to boost self-esteem, increase gratitude, or regulate negative emotion
Tory Higgins’ self-discrepancy theory (1987) adds another layer, describing the gap between our actual self, our ideal self, and our ‘ought’ self – the person we feel obliged to be. Crucially, the ideal and ought selves are rarely self-generated. They’re built from internalized parents, teachers, cultural expectations, and partners. The size of the gap between who we feel we are and who we feel we should be is strongly correlated with anxiety and depressive symptoms – and that gap was, in large part, handed to us by other people.
Higgins argued that the gap between actual and Ideal represents the absence of positive outcomes. It triggers dejection-related emotions like sadness, disappointment, depression, and shame. The gap between actual and ought represents the presence of a threat or punishment. It triggers agitation-related emotions like anxiety, guilt, tension, and fear. Higgins also noted that these selves are viewed from two different vantage points, which are an individual’s personal standpoint, and the standpoint of a significant other (eg a parent, partner, or society).
Attachment theory rounds this out by showing how early relationships create a template for what connection feels safe, and what kind of self is ‘acceptable’ within it. A child who reliably experiences warmth and responsiveness tends to develop a self that feels fundamentally OK. A child whose early relationships were inconsistent, critical, or withdrawn tends to develop a self that feels – often for the rest of their life – provisional, on approval, or not quite enough.
John Bowlby proposed that early attachment relationships do more than determine how secure children feel in childhood – they create what he called internal working models. These are deeply held assumptions about ourselves, other people, and relationships that operate largely outside conscious awareness.
A child who consistently experiences warmth and reliability may develop beliefs such as, “I am worthy of love”, “Other people can be trusted”, and “When I need help, someone will be there”. By contrast, inconsistent, neglectful, or critical caregiving may foster beliefs such as, “I am unimportant”, “People will eventually reject me”, or “I have to cope on my own”.
These internal working models often persist into adulthood, quietly shaping friendships, romantic relationships, parenting, and even interactions with therapists. Clients frequently respond to present-day relationships according to expectations that were formed many years earlier. Therapy offers repeated opportunities for those expectations to be updated through new, emotionally corrective experiences.
Carl Rogers (1902-1987) added another important piece to understanding how our sense of self develops. He believed that every child has an innate drive toward psychological growth, but whether that growth flourishes depends largely on the kind of acceptance they receive from the significant people in their lives.
When children experience unconditional positive regard – being loved and valued simply for who they are – they tend to develop a stable and accepting view of themselves. However, many children learn that approval is conditional. They discover that affection, praise, or acceptance only follow certain behaviours: being quiet, achieving highly, avoiding mistakes, looking after others, or never showing anger. Rogers called these learned expectations ‘conditions of worth’.
Over time, these external conditions become internal rules. Instead of asking, “What do I genuinely want or need?”, people begin asking, “What must I do to deserve acceptance?” Many clients who struggle with perfectionism, people-pleasing, or chronic self-criticism are still living according to conditions of worth they learned decades earlier. One aim of therapy is to help clients distinguish between their authentic values and the expectations they have unconsciously inherited from others.
How it works in everyday life
A single offhand comment from, for example, a teacher, such as “you’re not really a maths person”, can quietly calcify into a lifelong belief, repeated internally for decades after the teacher who said it has been forgotten. A parent’s disappointment, expressed just once, can become the internal voice a client hears every time they consider taking a risk.
Sometimes these comments are communicated indirectly through neglect, inconsistency, criticism, or unrealistic expectations. Whichever way it is, eventually, these external opinions become internal beliefs. The client no longer hears a parent’s criticism or a teacher’s disappointment. Instead, they hear their own inner voice repeating the same message.
Modern life adds an accelerant: social media turns Festinger’s sideways glance into a constant, algorithmically curated stream of comparison points, most of them showing other people’s highlight reels rather than their reality.
Many people assume that their inner critic represents objective truth. Yet when therapists gently ask, “Whose voice does that sound like?”, the answer is often immediate – “My father, my schoolteacher, my ex-partner, my older brother”, for example. Over time, an individual’s brain stops distinguishing between the original speaker and the internal narrator. The criticism feels as though it belongs to them. Recognizing this can be liberating. Clients begin to realize that they are not arguing with reality – they are replaying conversations from their past.
The American psychiatrist and psychoanalyst, Harry Stack Sullivan (1892–1949), called these figures ‘significant others’. He posited that our entire personality is formed within the interpersonal field. Anxiety, he argued, largely reflects the anticipation of interpersonal disapproval or rejection.
A client’s subconscious is not holding onto a ‘fact’ about their inadequacy. It is holding onto a relational memory – a neurological imprint of how someone made them feel at a formative moment.
These internalized representations of other people – their attitudes, expectations, and criticisms – are often called introjects. The client assumes these thoughts are their own, but they are merely ‘emotional anchors’ tied to past relationships. Unfortunately, many people spend their adult life filtering all current interactions through this old lens. They will actively seek out evidence to prove that belief true, ignoring any evidence to the contrary.
One of the more surprising findings in psychology is that people often prefer familiar beliefs about themselves – even painful ones – over uncertainty. William Swann’s self-verification theory (1981) suggests that individuals actively seek information that confirms their existing self-concept.
This helps explain why clients with low self-esteem sometimes dismiss compliments while readily accepting criticism. Positive feedback feels inconsistent with their established identity, whereas criticism feels familiar and therefore believable. Some people may even gravitate towards relationships that reinforce long-held negative beliefs because those interactions feel psychologically predictable.
Understanding this tendency can help therapists remain patient. When clients initially reject positive reframes or struggle to believe encouraging feedback, they are not being deliberately resistant. Their brains are simply trying to maintain a coherent and familiar sense of self. Lasting change usually requires repeated experiences that gradually make healthier beliefs feel just as credible as the old ones.
The brain predicts what it expects
Modern neuroscience suggests that the brain is constantly generating predictions about incoming sensory information. Rather than passively observing the world, it actively anticipates what is likely to happen based on previous experience.
If someone grew up believing that people are critical, their brain may automatically predict criticism in new situations. If they learned that making mistakes leads to humiliation, they may avoid opportunities where mistakes are possible.
These predictions influence what an individual notices, how they interpret events, and how they behave. A person expecting rejection may appear withdrawn. Others respond cautiously in return, unintentionally confirming the original expectation. The prediction becomes a behavioural confirmation effect, which is one form of self-fulfilling prophecy.
Psychologists refer to this tendency as confirmation bias. Once people hold a particular belief about themselves, they naturally notice evidence that supports it while overlooking evidence that contradicts it. A client who believes they are unlikeable may remember every awkward conversation but quickly forget the many occasions when people were warm, friendly, or appreciative. Therapy helps clients become aware of this selective filtering and intentionally collect evidence that supports a more balanced and compassionate view of themselves.
Psychologists often describe these deeply held beliefs as schemas – mental frameworks that help the brain organize information and make rapid predictions about the world. Schemas develop through repeated experience, particularly during childhood, and influence what people notice, remember, and expect.
For example, someone who develops a schema that “people cannot be trusted” is likely to pay greater attention to signs of rejection while overlooking evidence of kindness or acceptance. Similarly, a person whose schema says “I am not good enough” may interpret neutral situations as criticism or assume that success happened through luck rather than ability.
Schemas are useful because they allow the brain to process enormous amounts of information efficiently. However, when they become outdated or distorted, they can continue generating predictions that no longer reflect reality. Therapy helps clients identify these automatic assumptions and gradually replace them with more flexible, evidence-based alternatives.
Labels become identities
Children are remarkably receptive to labels. “The clever one, the shy one, the difficult child, the sensitive one, the sporty one” – if these descriptions are repeated often enough, they begin to feel like permanent identities rather than temporary observations.
Yet people are always more complex than any label. Someone described as ‘shy’ at the age of six may become an excellent public speaker. A child labelled ‘lazy’ may simply have struggled with undiagnosed learning difficulties, anxiety, or low confidence. Therapy often involves helping clients separate who they are from what they were once called.
This process does not end in childhood. Partners influence one another’s confidence. Friends affect our optimism. Colleagues shape our professional identity. Communities reinforce our values. Even social media subtly encourages us to compare ourselves with carefully edited versions of other people’s lives. We continue absorbing information about ourselves throughout adulthood. Fortunately, this means positive relationships can also reshape our self-image.
Why this matters clinically
Many of the issues clients bring – anxiety, low self-worth, perfectionism, rejection sensitivity – are often framed, by clients themselves, as evidence of some internal deficiency. “I’m just not confident. I’m too sensitive. Something’s wrong with me.”
Rather than challenging these statements directly, solution-focused hypnotherapy invites clients to consider exceptions, strengths, resources, and possibilities. As clients begin noticing occasions when they cope well, solve problems, or enjoy life, their brains receive fresh evidence. New experiences gradually compete with old predictions. The internal story begins to change.
Understanding the self as substantially co-authored by other people offers a different, more workable frame: the problem is not a broken internal mechanism, but a set of internalized voices, comparisons, and expectations that were absorbed – often accurately reflecting someone else’s fear, projection, or unmet standard rather than any truth about the client.
This reframe matters for a few reasons:
It’s more accurate – most distressing self-beliefs genuinely do have an origin story involving other people, rather than emerging spontaneously from nowhere.
It’s more hopeful – a belief that was learned relationally can be renegotiated relationally. A belief treated as an intrinsic, fixed trait feels far harder to shift.
It explains why relationships matter in the therapy room itself – the therapeutic relationship isn’t incidental to the technique – for a client whose self-concept was shaped by critical or inconsistent relationships, a consistently respectful, non-judgemental relationship with a therapist can itself begin to function as corrective evidence.
For solution-focused hypnotherapy specifically, this connects directly to why the approach works the way it does. Indirect suggestion and reframing aren’t just relaxing the client – they’re offering an alternative to the internalized critical voice, in language gentle enough that the conscious, defensive mind doesn’t block it. And the future-focused emphasis of SFH – building a preferred future from existing resources – helps clients construct a new reflected self, built from an imagined more supportive audience, rather than endlessly re-litigating the old one.
Hypnotherapy is not simply about relaxation or suggestion. The relationship itself is therapeutic. When clients consistently experience curiosity instead of criticism, acceptance instead of judgement, and encouragement instead of doubt, they experience something many have rarely known. They begin to see themselves through different eyes. Each session becomes another piece of evidence that they are capable, resilient, resourceful, and worthy of respect. This is one reason why the quality of the therapeutic relationship predicts positive outcomes across many forms of psychotherapy. Sometimes people borrow a kinder way of seeing themselves before they are able to generate it independently.
The good news
Perhaps the most hopeful discovery clients can make is that they were not born believing they were inadequate, they learned it. And what is learned can, with patience and repeated experience, be revised.
Our brains remain capable of change throughout life. New relationships, new experiences, and new ways of thinking continually reshape the neural pathways that support our beliefs about ourselves. Every encouraging conversation, every small success, every act of compassion, and every therapeutic breakthrough provides the brain with fresh evidence.
Our identity is not fixed. It is a story that continues to be written. As hypnotherapists, we have the privilege of helping clients become the author of the next chapter rather than remaining bound by earlier drafts written by other people.
Other ways to help the client all fit around the idea of treating the internalized relationships as the problem. Here are some examples of what to do:
Reframe the problem for your client. Instead of saying, “You suffer from imposter syndrome”, say, ”You are carrying the outdated expectations of a past authority figure”. This externalization removes shame. It tells the client: ”It is not your fault, but it is your responsibility to release it”. When the problem is outside of them, they stop fighting themselves and start fighting the echo.
In trance, guide your client toward the realization that they are not the voice that criticizes them; they are the one listening to the voice.
For homework, ask the client, ”If no one else existed on earth, what would you actually enjoy doing?”. This strips away their performative identity. Secondly, encourage them to actively spend more time with people in whom they feel expansive (safe, tall, relaxed) and drastically less time with people in whom they feel contractive (anxious, small, defensive). Remind them that self-esteem is maintained through interaction, not just introspection.
Psychologist Dan McAdams argues that people make sense of their lives by constructing a narrative identity – an evolving life story that explains who they are, where they have come from, and where they believe they are going. Like all stories, however, these narratives are selective. They emphasize certain events while minimizing or overlooking others.
Clients who see themselves as “a failure” or “someone who is always rejected” are often telling a story built around a limited number of painful experiences while overlooking countless examples of resilience, kindness, competence, or growth. Therapy is not about inventing a false story; it is about helping clients construct a fuller and more balanced account of their lives – one that includes strengths as well as struggles. As that story changes, so too does the person’s sense of who they are.
Conclusion
Other people have had a big role in shaping how any individual sees themself – even us. And this happens often without the individual’s consent, and sometimes unfairly. But the very fact that this shaping is a process rather than a fixed truth is what makes change possible.
The role of the therapist is to help the client see the social mirror for what it is. Help them to realize that their true self is not found in the reflection of others’ eyes, it is found in the quiet, steady presence that has been there all along, underneath the noise
Once a client can see the mechanism – that their self-concept was constructed rather than discovered – they gain something valuable: the ability to consciously choose, going forward, whose reflection they are willing to trust.
Our sense of self is never created in isolation, and it is never permanently fixed. Every conversation, every relationship, every act of encouragement or criticism subtly updates the story our brain tells us about who we are. The same social brain that once learned “I’m not good enough” is capable of learning “Perhaps I always was”. As therapists, we do not simply help clients solve problems – we become part of the social environment from which a healthier, more compassionate sense of self can emerge.
References:
Bowlby, J. (1969) Attachment and Loss. Volume 1: Attachment. London: Hogarth Press.
Bowlby, J. (1973) Attachment and Loss. Volume 2: Separation: Anxiety and Anger. London: Hogarth Press.
Coan, J.A. (2010) ‘Adult attachment and the brain’, Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 27(2), pp. 210–217.
Coan, J.A., Schaefer, H.S. and Davidson, R.J. (2006) ‘Lending a hand: Social regulation of the neural response to threat’, Psychological Science, 17(12), pp. 1032–1039.
Cooley, C.H. (1902) Human Nature and the Social Order. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons.
Festinger, L. (1954) ‘A theory of social comparison processes’, Human Relations, 7(2), pp. 117–140.
Higgins, E.T. (1987) ‘Self-discrepancy: A theory relating self and affect’, Psychological Review, 94(3), pp. 319–340.
McAdams, D.P. (1993) The Stories We Live By: Personal Myths and the Making of the Self. New York: William Morrow.
Mead, G.H. (1934) Mind, Self and Society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Porges, S.W. (2011) The Polyvagal Theory: Neurophysiological Foundations of Emotions, Attachment, Communication, Self-regulation. New York: W.W. Norton.
Rogers, C.R. (1951) Client-Centered Therapy. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Rogers, C.R. (1961) On Becoming a Person. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Sullivan, H.S. (1953) The Interpersonal Theory of Psychiatry. New York: W.W. Norton.
Swann, W.B. Jr. (1983) ‘Self-verification: Bringing social reality into harmony with the self’, in Suls, J. and Greenwald, A.G. (eds.) Psychological Perspectives on the Self. Vol. 2. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, pp. 33–66

